The Cost of a Bad Background Screening Process

Noel Diem |

Are you familiar with the saying, “What you don’t know can’t hurt you”? When it comes to background screening during hiring, that couldn’t be further from the truth.

In fact, what you don’t know about your potential employees could end up costing your business dearly. From missed red flags to negligent hires, a bad background screening process can have far-reaching consequences for any organization.

Understanding the Background Screening Process: Explained

On the surface, we all know what background screening is. However, few organizations and HR professionals understand it.

It’s Not Like TV

You’ve seen the dramatic portrayals of background screenings revealing shocking secrets. In reality, background screening is not as glamorous or fast-paced. It’s a meticulous process that requires time and attention to detail.

Unlike on TV, conducting a thorough background check can take several days or weeks. It involves gathering information from different sources, including:

  • Criminal records
  • Employment history
  • Education
  • References

This might make it challenging to plan your hiring!

Within AssureHire’s background screening software, you get an average of how long it takes to get the screening back. This helps you hire faster and make smarter decisions.

While television exaggerates how quickly the process is, real-life situations require careful attention to multiple factors. But don’t cut down on your screening. Always opt toward meeting professional standards.

What Employers Look at

When it comes to background screening, employers have a keen eye for details. They want to ensure that they are making informed decisions when hiring new employees. So, what exactly do employers look at during the background screening process?

First and foremost, employers typically verify an applicant’s identity. This includes checking their Social Security number, driver’s license information, and any other relevant identification documents. It is essential for employers to confirm that the person applying for the job is who they claim to be.

Employers also take a close look at an applicant’s employment history. They want to know if the candidate has been truthful about their past positions, responsibilities, and dates of employment. Any discrepancies or gaps in work history can raise red flags.

Another crucial aspect of background screening is conducting criminal record checks. Employers want to ensure that potential hires do not have any serious criminal convictions that could pose a risk to the company or its employees.

Additionally, many employers consider credit reports as part of their background screening process. While this practice may vary depending on the industry and position being filled, some companies believe that an individual’s financial responsibility reflects their character and reliability.

Employers may also check an applicant’s educational credentials by verifying degrees earned from universities or colleges. This helps them determine if candidates possess the qualifications they claim to have.

For a full explainer of what background screening can do, refer to our blog here.

Criminal Background Check

Consequences of Ignoring Background Screening

When hiring new employees, many employers underestimate the importance of conducting thorough background screenings. Ignoring this crucial step in the hiring process can have severe consequences for both the company and its existing workforce.

Neglecting background screening can expose your organization to potential legal issues. Hiring individuals without properly vetting their backgrounds could result in liability if they engage in illegal activities or pose a risk to others while on the job. This negligence could lead to lawsuits, damage to your company’s reputation, and financial losses that could have been avoided.

Failing to conduct proper background checks can put your current employees at risk. By not thoroughly assessing an applicant’s criminal history, you may unknowingly hire someone with a violent past or a propensity for theft. This puts your team members’ safety and well-being in jeopardy.

Additionally, ignoring background screening opens the door for unqualified candidates to slip through the cracks. You need to verify education credentials, employment history, or professional licenses to avoid bringing on individuals who lack the necessary skills or qualifications for their roles. This can hinder productivity and impact overall business performance.

Moreover, skipping background checks can also harm workplace morale and employee trust. If existing staff members discover that new hires were not properly screened before being brought onboard, it sends a message that their safety and security are not valued by their employer. This erosion of trust can negatively impact employee engagement and loyalty.

Why Background Screening is Essential

When it comes to hiring new employees, businesses can’t afford to take chances. That’s where background screening comes in. By conducting comprehensive background checks on potential hires, employers can gain valuable insights into an individual’s past and make more informed decisions about their suitability for the job.

Background screening involves:

  • Verifying a candidate’s personal information.
  • Checking their employment history.
  • Confirming their educational qualifications.
  • Even delving into their criminal records if necessary.

It provides a holistic view of an applicant that goes beyond what can be gleaned from just a resume or interview.

better background screening

There are several benefits to implementing a robust background screening process. It helps mitigate the risk of hiring individuals who may pose a threat to the safety and well-being of other employees or customers. By identifying any red flags early on, employers can avoid potentially detrimental situations down the line.

Background screening enables companies to protect their reputation and brand image. Hiring someone with a questionable past could tarnish the organization’s credibility and trustworthiness in the eyes of clients or stakeholders.

Furthermore, conducting thorough background checks ensures compliance with industry regulations and standards. Certain industries have specific requirements for employee screenings due to legal obligations or security concerns. Failing to adhere to these guidelines could result in hefty fines or legal repercussions.

In addition, by investing in modern technology solutions for background checks, companies can streamline the hiring process and save time and resources. Automated systems allow for faster turnaround times while maintaining accuracy and consistency across all candidates.

Having customizable background screening solutions means that businesses of all sizes can benefit from this essential practice without breaking the bank. Whether you’re a small startup or an established corporation with hundreds of employees, there are options available that cater specifically to your needs.

Software for Background Screening Process

Benefits of a Formal Background Screening Process

A comprehensive background screening process offers numerous benefits to employers. Companies can make more informed hiring decisions and protect their business interests by conducting thorough checks on potential employees. 

Here are some key advantages of implementing a robust background screening policy:

  1. Enhanced Safety and Security: Background screenings help ensure that individuals with a history of violence, criminal activity, or substance abuse do not enter the workplace. This helps create a safer environment for all employees and reduces the risk of incidents such as theft or workplace harassment.
  2. Protecting Company Reputation: Hiring an employee with a questionable background can damage your company’s reputation in the long run. Conducting background checks allows you to hire trustworthy individuals who align with your company values, preserving your brand image.
  3. Decreased Employee Turnover: Implementing effective background screening processes can lead to better candidate selection and ultimately reduce organizational turnover rates. Employers can avoid making costly hiring mistakes by identifying red flags early on.
  4. Compliance with Industry Regulations: Various industries have specific regulations regarding employee qualifications and safety standards that must be met. Background screenings help ensure compliance with these regulations while avoiding legal issues and penalties.
  5. Improved Quality of Hires: Hiring candidates with verified credentials, relevant experience, and clean backgrounds increases the likelihood of finding qualified professionals who will contribute positively to your organization’s success.

Reducing Risks: An Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE) study found that companies with proper background screening programs experienced 28% fewer occupational fraud and abuse instances.

The Consequences of a Bad Background Screening Process

The consequences of neglecting background screening in the hiring process can be severe and far-reaching. Without proper screening, employers leave themselves open to a wide range of risks and potential problems.

By not conducting thorough background checks, employers may unknowingly hire individuals with criminal records or a history of fraudulent behavior. This puts the company at risk of financial loss, damage to reputation, and even legal liabilities.

Neglecting background screening can result in poor hiring decisions. Hiring someone without verifying their qualifications or job history can lead to mismatched skill sets and poor performance on the job. This not only wastes time and resources but also affects overall productivity and employee morale.

Additionally, failing to screen candidates properly can create a negative workplace environment. Employees may feel uneasy or unsafe working alongside individuals who have undisclosed criminal pasts or questionable backgrounds. This can impact teamwork, trust among colleagues, and ultimately affect the overall work culture within the organization.

Neglecting background screening also opens up possibilities for internal theft or fraud within the company. By bypassing this crucial step in the hiring process, employers inadvertently make it easier for dishonest individuals to gain access to sensitive information or engage in unethical behaviors that could harm both employees and customers alike.

Neglecting background screening is a risky move that can have significant consequences for an organization. It is essential for employers to prioritize thorough screenings as part of their hiring process to minimize these risks and ensure they are making informed decisions when bringing new employees on board.

The High Cost of Making Bad Hiring Decisions

When it comes to hiring new employees, making the wrong choice can have serious consequences for your business. From a financial perspective, the cost of a bad hire can be astronomical. Not only will you waste time and resources on training someone who ultimately isn’t a good fit, but there’s also the cost of having to repeat the entire hiring process again.

But it’s not just about money. A bad hire can also damage your company’s reputation and morale. If an employee turns out to be incompetent or unreliable, it can negatively impact team dynamics and productivity.

Furthermore, there may be legal ramifications if you fail to conduct proper background screening and end up with an employee who poses a risk to others in the workplace. This could result in lawsuits or even fines imposed by regulatory bodies.

Additionally, consider the potential damage that could occur if sensitive information falls into the wrong hands due to inadequate vetting procedures. The fallout from data breaches or intellectual property theft can be devastating both financially and in terms of trust with your customers.

Failing to prioritize background screening when making hiring decisions is simply not worth the risk. By investing in thorough screening processes upfront, you’ll save yourself from potential headaches down the line and ensure that you’re bringing on board candidates who are qualified, trustworthy, and aligned with your company values.

How to Establish a Reliable Background Screening Process

Establishing a reliable background screening process is crucial for any organization looking to make informed hiring decisions. Here are some best practices to follow when implementing this process.

It’s essential to conduct a thorough employment background check. This involves verifying an applicant’s identity, checking their credit reports, and reviewing their criminal records. By gathering this information, employers can assess whether a candidate has been honest in their application and evaluate potential risks associated with the individual.

Determining the scope and duration of background checks is also essential. Different positions may require different levels of scrutiny based on the nature of the job responsibilities and industry regulations. For example, roles that involve handling sensitive information or working with vulnerable populations may necessitate more extensive screenings.

To ensure consistency and accuracy in your screening process, consider partnering with a reputable background check service provider like AssureHire. They offer comprehensive solutions tailored to businesses of all sizes, allowing you to customize your screening criteria according to your specific needs.

Integrating your background screening process seamlessly into your Applicant Tracking System (ATS) or Human Resources Information System (HRIS) can significantly improve efficiency by automating certain tasks and streamlining workflows.

By following these best practices and utilizing modern technology solutions like AssureHire’s services, organizations can establish a reliable background screening process that helps mitigate risk, maintain compliance with relevant laws, protect brand reputation, and ultimately make better-informed hiring decisions.

To see more, schedule a demo with our AssureHire team today!

Our focus? On your success.

Schedule a demo, or learn more about Mitratech’s products, services, and commitment.